Gorilla vs Lion vs Bear: Who Wins? | John Danaher and Lex Fridman

Procesado:

💭 Hacer Pregunta

💬 Historial de Preguntas

Considerando todos los argumentos, no hay un ganador claro y la respuesta depende del contexto.

  • En una pelea en la naturaleza: El león tendría una ventaja significativa debido a su experiencia en combate, habilidad para iniciar el ataque y capacidad de terminar la pelea rápidamente. El oso podría resistir debido a su tamaño y resistencia, pero probablemente se retiraría antes de un enfrentamiento a muerte.

  • En una pelea enjaulada sin posibilidad de escape: El oso tendría una ventaja debido a su mayor tamaño, fuerza y resistencia. La pelea probablemente se prolongaría, y el resultado dependería de la resistencia de cada animal.

  • En una pelea con tiempo limitado (ej. 5 rounds): El león tendría una ventaja debido a su velocidad y capacidad de infligir daño rápidamente. El oso podría resistir, pero es menos probable que pueda causar un daño significativo antes de que termine la pelea.

En resumen, el león tiene la ventaja en la mayoría de los escenarios, excepto en una pelea enjaulada sin límite de tiempo donde el oso tendría las mejores posibilidades.

2025-08-27

📊 Análisis

Gorilla vs Lion vs Bear Resumen

RESUMEN

Debate Gorilla vs León vs Oso: ¿Quién gana?

Este video presenta un debate entre John Danaher y Lex Fridman sobre quién ganaría en una pelea a muerte entre un oso grizzly, un gorila espalda plateada y un león africano. Analizan varios factores, incluyendo inteligencia, peso, fuerza, fuerza de mordida, agresión y experiencia en combate. La conclusión general es que la pelea depende mucho del escenario (naturaleza versus jaula) y que determinar un ganador definitivo es complejo y altamente especulativo, dada la falta de datos sobre combates inter-especies.

IDEAS CLAVE

Factores Determinantes del Combate

  • Inteligencia: El gorila es considerado el más inteligente, pero su inteligencia no se traduce necesariamente en una ventaja significativa en el combate, donde la experiencia juega un papel crucial.
  • Peso y Fuerza: El oso grizzly tiene una gran ventaja en peso y fuerza bruta, pero la fuerza del gorila para cargar objetos es sorprendente.
  • Fuerza de Mordida: El gorila tiene la mordida más fuerte, sorprendentemente, a pesar de ser herbívoro.
  • Experiencia de Combate: El león tiene una vasta experiencia de combate, enfrentándose regularmente a presas peligrosas como búfalos y elefantes. Los osos y gorilas tienen menos experiencia en combates a muerte.
  • Capacidad de Iniciación y Disengage: La capacidad de iniciar el combate y de retirarse del mismo se destaca como puntos críticos, con una ventaja para los felinos.
  • Método de Finalización: Se destaca que la capacidad de terminar la pelea eficientemente es crucial; el león, con su técnica de estrangulamiento, tiene una ventaja en este punto. Ni el oso ni el gorila tienen métodos de finalización tan eficientes.
  • Resistencia: El oso es superior en resistencia, pero los leones son cazadores más explosivos y rápidos.

Análisis de Cada Animal

  • Gorila: Posee inteligencia y fuerza de mordida, pero carece de experiencia de combate a muerte y métodos eficientes de finalización. Su combate es principalmente teatral.
  • León: Gran experiencia en combate, técnicas de finalización eficientes (estrangulamiento), alta velocidad y capacidad de Ambush. Su comportamiento social permite mayor toma de riesgos.
  • Oso Grizzly: Gran fuerza y resistencia, pero carece de la experiencia de combate del león y tiene dificultad para finalizar la pelea. Tiene tendencia a la evitación del riesgo.

Conclusión

En un escenario natural, la probabilidad de que alguno de ellos mate a otro se considera baja, con el león potencialmente asustando al oso grizzly, pero en una confrontación contenida (como en una jaula), el oso grizzly tendría una ligera ventaja debido a su tamaño y resistencia.

INSIGHTS

El debate resalta la importancia de contextualizar las capacidades de un animal. La fuerza y el tamaño no son los únicos factores determinantes en una pelea; la experiencia, la agilidad, y la estrategia juegan un papel igual de importante. La intuición inicial sobre las capacidades de lucha de un animal puede ser engañosa.

La discusión también subraya la falta de datos concretos sobre combates inter-especies, enfatizando la dificultad de llegar a una conclusión definitiva sin evidencia empírica concluyente.

Finalmente, se plantea la cuestión de las limitaciones de aplicar conceptos de combate humano a animales, especialmente en la evaluación de sus estrategias y capacidades.

🎯 Sabiduría

Gorilla vs Lion vs Bear: Análisis del video

RESUMEN

John Danaher y Lex Fridman discuten quién ganaría en una pelea entre un gorila, un león y un oso, considerando la inteligencia, el peso, la fuerza, la fuerza de mordida y la agresión.

IDEAS

  • La inteligencia del gorila es notable, mostrando emociones complejas y uso de herramientas.
  • Un oso pardo puede pesar hasta 1500 libras, el doble que un león.
  • Los gorilas pueden cargar 10 veces su peso corporal, más de 4000 libras.
  • La fuerza de mordida del gorila es la más alta, con 1300 PSI.
  • Los gorilas carecen de cuello, lo que afecta su capacidad de lucha.
  • La estrangulación es un método de caza común entre los leones.
  • Los tigres y osos usan sus garras en combate, a diferencia de los gorillas.
  • Las intuiciones iniciales sobre la fuerza animal pueden ser engañosas.
  • Las habilidades, atributos y experiencia son cruciales en el combate.
  • La iniciación y el desenganche son elementos importantes en la lucha.
  • Tener un método eficiente para finalizar una pelea es clave.
  • La capacidad de aguantar más que el oponente es fundamental.
  • La concentración de fuerza, las tácticas de emboscada y la resistencia son estrategias de combate efectivas.
  • La mayoría de la experiencia de combate del gorila es teatral, no letal.
  • Los leones tienen mucha experiencia de combate por su estilo de vida competitivo.
  • Los leones regularmente cazan animales peligrosos como búfalos del Cabo.
  • La tasa de mortalidad en las peleas entre leones machos es muy alta.
  • Los leones, al ser sociales, pueden correr más riesgos que los animales solitarios.
  • Los leopardos a menudo matan gorilas, cuestionando la capacidad de lucha de estos últimos.
  • Los leones tienen una mejor concentración de fuerza con sus garras y colmillos.
  • Los osos pardos poseen gran fuerza y resistencia, pero son reacios al riesgo.
  • Los osos pardos pueden superar a los leones en resistencia, pero no en inicio ni finalización de la pelea.
  • Los antiguos romanos documentaron peleas entre animales, incluyendo tigres y leones.
  • Las peleas entre animales proporcionan información limitada sobre las capacidades de lucha.
  • La falta de experiencia de combate en los osos contra animales de gran tamaño limita sus posibilidades.
  • En una jaula, un oso pardo podría tener ventaja debido a la resistencia.
  • En un combate corto, un león podría tener ventaja por su velocidad y capacidad de emboscada.
  • En circunstancias normales o en la naturaleza, predomina la naturaleza evasiva del oso, lo que le da una ventaja implícita.

INSIGHTS

  • La experiencia de combate es tan crucial como la fuerza bruta.
  • Las intuiciones iniciales sobre la fuerza son frecuentemente engañosas.
  • La capacidad de finalizar una pelea determina el éxito.
  • La estrategia es tan importante como la fuerza física.
  • La naturaleza social influye en la agresividad y la toma de riesgos.
  • La inteligencia puede ser una ventaja, pero requiere tiempo para desarrollarse.
  • El estudio de las luchas de animales históricos ofrece información valiosa.
  • La capacidad de disuadir a un oponente a través de la intimidación puede llegar a ser muy efectiva.
  • En las luchas de animales es un común denominador que pocos ataques resultan en muertes.
  • Las estrategias evasivas tienen un peso importante a la hora de decidir una lucha entre animales.

CITAS

  • "...el gorila es el más inteligente."
  • "Los gorilas pueden cargar 10 veces su peso corporal."
  • "La fuerza de mordida del gorila es la más alta de todas."
  • "...casi todas las experiencias de combate de un gorila son teatrales."
  • "Los leones tienen una experiencia de combate sin igual en el reino animal."
  • "Los leones regularmente cazan animales peligrosos como búfalos del Cabo."
  • "...las intuiciones no deben ser confiables."
  • "...habilidades, atributos y experiencia determinan el éxito en el combate."
  • "La iniciación y el desenganche son importantes."
  • "La concentración de fuerza, las tácticas de emboscada y la resistencia son estrategias clave."
  • "Los osos pardos son muy fuertes, pero se muestran reacios al riesgo."
  • "...un león proporcionaría suficiente amenaza para que un oso retrocediera."
  • "En una jaula, favorecería al oso por su resistencia."
  • "Gordon, vas a morir muy mal."
  • "Esto no es una cuestión de objetivos audaces, es una cuestión de minimizar el dolor."

HÁBITOS

  • Investigación exhaustiva sobre temas específicos (Danaher).
  • Observación de videos de animales para análisis de combate (Danaher).
  • Análisis crítico de las intuiciones iniciales (Danaher).
  • Enfoque en la estrategia y la técnica (Danaher).
  • Aconsejar a los atletas a minimizar el riesgo y el daño potencial (Danaher).

HECHOS

  • Un león grande puede pesar hasta 550 libras.
  • Un oso pardo puede pesar hasta 1500 libras.
  • Los gorilas pueden levantar más de 2000 kilogramos.
  • La fuerza de mordida de un gorila es de 1300 PSI.
  • Los leopardos usan una técnica específica para matar gorilas, atacando la arteria femoral.
  • Los leones matan a aproximadamente 240 humanos por año.
  • Los leones tienen una velocidad máxima de 45 a 50 millas por hora.
  • Los osos pardos pueden correr durante largos periodos a 25 millas por hora.
  • Los osos pardos son a menudo echados por pumas y glotones.
  • Los antiguos romanos llevaban a cabo combates entre animales.

REFERENCIAS

  • Joe Rogan
  • Mike Tyson
  • Gordon Ryan
  • Estudios de gorilas a lo largo de 12 años.
  • Videos de YouTube de animales en combate.
  • Documentos de los antiguos romanos sobre peleas entre animales.

CONCLUSIÓN EN UNA FRASE

La experiencia de combate, la estrategia y la capacidad de finalizar la pelea superan la fuerza bruta.

RECOMENDACIONES

  • Desconfía de tus intuiciones iniciales al evaluar la fuerza animal.
  • Considera la habilidad, los atributos y la experiencia en el combate.
  • Prioriza la capacidad de iniciar, desenganchar y finalizar una pelea.
  • Reconoce la importancia de la concentración de fuerza, la emboscada y la resistencia.
  • Evalúa la naturaleza social de un animal para comprender mejor su comportamiento.
  • Investiga diferentes casos de animales en combate para obtener un entendimiento más completo del comportamiento animal.
  • Aprende a minimizar riesgos en cualquier tipo de lucha.

🔮 Sabiduría PRO

Powered by SOLUTORIA AI

who wins<br>in a fight to the death<br>or maybe a uh in a sport competition<br>setting but let's go with a fight to the<br>death uh a grizzly bear<br>a Silverback Gorilla<br>and maybe a lion or tiger an African<br>lion or uh one of the flavors of tiger<br>I don't know who you think is more<br>ferocious what are the parameters to<br>consider here maybe I can throw a few<br>out and maybe you can give me<br>some thoughts about how much of these<br>parameters matter so first of all<br>intelligence<br>I do believe the gorilla is the most<br>intelligent I've did research for this<br>as you can imagine<br>[Laughter]<br>with Joe Rogan uh the the expert advisor<br>to this very podcast on this very topic<br>is indeed Joe Rogan yes uh so in<br>captivity guerrillas have been<br>documented to show complex emotions from<br>family bonds the ability to use tools<br>and to be able to reason about the past<br>and the future that's impressive so that<br>that's something that at least in<br>captivity the other animals have not<br>been able to do they already sound much<br>more advanced than I am<br>um<br>yeah so<br>that's intelligence then there is weight<br>I think that's something that you think<br>of at first uh the lion let's go with<br>the big ones that I took notes Here 550<br>pounds for big lion that's exceptionally<br>large like most male lines are around<br>450 pounds that's an exceptional Beast<br>then<br>thank you<br>um the the tiger can be larger than that<br>yeah much much larger<br>so we got the grizzly bear which is<br>probably the biggest of the bunch at uh<br>the large ones get to uh 1500 pounds<br>correct me some of this numbers I<br>believe most Grizzlies around a thousand<br>pounds big big beast I was looking up<br>the biggest but I didn't want to do the<br>biggest ever<br>I just wanted the big like the top of<br>the range because there's always the<br>range you can put it in a roughly double<br>that of even a very big lion<br>of course how that weight is used is<br>very important uh so there's also things<br>which I find is interesting as Anaconda<br>would just let me throw that in there<br>because there is 200 pounds what I<br>really like about that is it's not just<br>the way it's the form factor and I think<br>out of all of these the ancana is the<br>most<br>non-standard form factor which I totally<br>agree with that yeah it's like the the<br>uh the Knight on the chessboard it comes<br>in from a completely different angle so<br>we got that we got also uh<br>a strength in which could be measured in<br>ability to carry stuff so this was<br>surprising to me I did look into this<br>carefully the grizzly bear at a thousand<br>or 1500 pounds can only carry at most<br>its body weight which is a lot<br>but a gorilla can carry 10 times his<br>body weight a gorilla can lift over 2<br>000 kilograms that's over four thousand<br>pounds and gorillas themselves and adult<br>male weighs in around 350 to 400 400<br>pounds yes that's so I like how in this<br>particular place where I found this to 2<br>000 kilograms is as heavy as 30 average<br>humans so gorillas<br>30 humans so that's carrying string and<br>then of course uh bite force because<br>that's one of the weapons in question<br>here so agree now this is really<br>surprising to me I the gorilla has won<br>me over through this by the way uh<br>intelligence I'm gonna sucker for<br>intelligence but the gorilla bite force<br>is the highest of all these with 1300<br>PSI bear a second with 1200 PSI tiger is<br>uh a third I think tiger and lions<br>they're with a thousand PSI that's<br>comparable and a bear is uh anywhere<br>from 900 to 1000 PSI they're close but<br>gorilla I would not have expected now<br>that's gorilla is not a carnivore but<br>apparently you choose it's mostly it's<br>grassy stuff right but it like<br>it's difficult to explain why it has<br>such a powerful bite and it also of<br>course has very large in size of teeth<br>as well as chewing teeth so um also no<br>neck yeah<br>so because Nick begins at the top of his<br>head and this goes down to the shoulders<br>well a lot of the way they use their<br>teeth<br>all of these animals they the the<br>ultimate kill is to go for the neck the<br>bite in the neck I don't know exactly<br>why that is probably<br>has to do<br>why is that because it's a very strong<br>controlled position not just that it's a<br>is it the same as Jiu-Jitsu you think<br>because they get to also choke them out<br>it's very much in line with you just<br>like lions are famous for using<br>strangulation as their primary method of<br>killing they they get a hold of the neck<br>and hold until<br>um the animal drops plus uh claws<br>I believe the tiger and the bear use<br>their claws and the lion too the lion<br>right and the lion uh<br>this is something that the gorilla<br>doesn't do<br>and uh Anaconda obviously doesn't yeah<br>so what what do you think how do we<br>think about this also there is uh I'm<br>just not letting you talk apparently<br>there's uh levels of aggression in terms<br>of these are also very important<br>considerations yeah what what is um all<br>the considerations you've raised are<br>very important and we we would have to<br>address them if we're going to go<br>through this topic<br>um first things first<br>whenever you go into a discussion of<br>this kind there's<br>a kind of natural impression that we all<br>have as to which one would be the most<br>formidable<br>um<br>and<br>it's important that you become rather<br>skeptical of your first intuitions<br>because they're often very misleading<br>just as every boy thinks his father is<br>the strongest man in the world<br>and then when he grows up into adulthood<br>he realizes<br>this father was not even close to being<br>the strongest man in the world it's not<br>because<br>of anything other than an experience to<br>a boy his father seemed overwhelmingly<br>strong he literally can't even imagine<br>if anyone else being stronger than that<br>so<br>naively he thinks his father is the<br>strongest man in the world so too in our<br>relationship with animals<br>when we look at a Silverback Gorilla it<br>just looks overwhelmingly strong to us<br>to a degree which is almost absurd like<br>um<br>you picture the greatest combat athletes<br>that Humanity has ever produced the<br>prime Mike Tyson Gordon Ryan for<br>grappling<br>they would literally be torn limb from<br>limb by an angry gorilla it wouldn't<br>even be remotely competitive and so<br>there's a sense in which we look at them<br>in awe because of what they could do to<br>us<br>but that can be very misleading and just<br>as a boy<br>looks at his father as like the Pinnacle<br>of strength you can't necessarily from a<br>position of inexperience and weakness<br>look at a given animal and say oh that<br>must be the toughest animal in the<br>animal kingdom there's levels to this<br>game and<br>um I think we can point out that the<br>gorilla ultimately would be pretty low<br>on those levels<br>push back to this analysis because the<br>data we don't have much data on this we<br>don't have we actually have slightly<br>more than you think I believe oh boy<br>well it's anecdotal I feel like it's out<br>of context so these species don't use<br>this is not MMA they don't do<br>inter-species fighting often<br>yeah but there are some ways of looking<br>at this which can take this already<br>interesting question and make it a lot<br>more interesting<br>um<br>first we've seen that intuitions aren't<br>to be trusted so if intuitions aren't to<br>be trusted or what is to be trusted here<br>well I've always believed that there are<br>three<br>General<br>elements that determine<br>what level of success or failure anyone<br>will experience in combat and this is<br>true both for individuals and for groups<br>and even all the way out to Nations<br>um<br>the first is what are your skills the<br>second is what are your physical and<br>mental attributes so it's skills<br>attributes those are the two primary<br>ones and there's a third<br>which is your experience in using those<br>skills and attributes and real world<br>scenarios okay so whenever two we'll<br>start with two humans when two humans<br>get into a fight ask yourself what is<br>their skill set<br>what are their physical and mental<br>attributes and what is their experience<br>and using those in real world<br>applications and that will give you your<br>first<br>look at uh okay who's going to be the<br>more successful<br>um<br>then in addition to those<br>three General elements there's also four<br>more specific elements<br>what is the ability<br>of the combatants to initiate combat<br>because initiation is a big deal in<br>fighting the one who sees the enemy<br>first and can create Ambush conditions<br>or<br>initiate compact combat in an area or a<br>Terrain which is favorable to them this<br>is huge in determining the uh the<br>outcome of battles<br>second<br>not only is initiation important but<br>disengagement is important a lot of<br>battles don't go according to plan and<br>so your ability to disengage at will and<br>break off and away from a battle is key<br>to success so initiation and<br>disengagement are big<br>the third big element<br>what is your ability to end a fight<br>okay do you have an efficient method of<br>ending conflict<br>without that<br>the conflict could go on to a point<br>where you no longer have the ability to<br>uh to continue it if you have some<br>succinct method of finishing this is<br>huge in combat and determining winner or<br>loser so both from a winning and a<br>losing position yeah so if you don't<br>have one there's a much higher chance<br>you'll lose but if you have an ability<br>to finish an opponent in the conflict uh<br>reliably this is<br>very very important in determining<br>success or failure<br>and third is your ability to endure a<br>conflict longer than the person you're<br>engaged in okay so engage with sorry and<br>so you get these four more specific<br>elements now do you have the ability to<br>initiate contact at will do you have the<br>ability to break contact and disengage<br>at will<br>do you have the ability to finish your<br>opponent efficiently and do you have the<br>ability to endure longer than your<br>opponent does if you have all four of<br>those<br>that's huge for for combat that probably<br>applies to human on human everything<br>military conflict everything even all<br>the way up to Nations<br>um<br>also ask yourself<br>what are the most efficient<br>methods of combat<br>across the globe across all species all<br>times<br>etc etc and you'll see that ultimately<br>they always come down to<br>three things<br>the first is concentration of force<br>okay one of the most successful<br>combat strategies of all time is the<br>ability to take<br>concentrated Force against a zone of<br>weakness in your opponent and if you can<br>do this<br>you will often break through to a point<br>of vulnerability attack that<br>vulnerability in a way where your<br>opponent cannot respond and cannot<br>recover from that vulnerable point being<br>broken do a high amount of damage with<br>Precision yes so this is one of the<br>great combat strategies in across the<br>animal kingdom across human history Etc<br>the second would be Ambush tactics<br>if you can Ambush an opponent with the<br>element of surprise this is huge for<br>success in combat they're almost all of<br>the truly successful Predators on this<br>planet are Ambush Predators<br>the ability to get off to a good start<br>in a way where opponents simply can't<br>recover is huge for combat are we<br>allowing ambush in our discussion<br>because humans would call this cheating<br>perhaps yes we would and<br>humans are pretty damn good at it too so<br>um uh and then the third is endurance<br>okay some uh<br>[Music]<br>species some people uh humans actually<br>are pretty good at this<br>um use endurance as a weapon and they<br>simply wear an opponent down over time<br>and break them and internationally this<br>can be done economically<br>um through numbers etc etc and uh and<br>you can destroy someone with just sheer<br>endurance yeah a lot of words throughout<br>human history has been Siege Warfare<br>yeah and so when you ask yourself okay<br>which one of these animals are going to<br>uh be the most successful in combat ask<br>yourself well there's these three<br>Elements which tend to determine<br>Successful Failure and warfare<br>um which animals exhibit these three<br>principles the best and we'll discuss<br>this but as far as um<br>uh generalities go uh whenever you ask a<br>question who will win between a and b<br>ask yourself<br>in terms of the light of what we've just<br>discussed<br>what is their skill set<br>what are the attributes both mental and<br>physical what is their experience in<br>utilizing these in real world situations<br>and then the four uh more technical<br>elements who gets to initiate contact<br>can you break off contact at any given<br>time uh what is your endurance can you<br>keep going uh longer than your opponent<br>does so a skill set I wonder if a big<br>component of that of how much practice<br>there is off off the battle exactly so<br>how much quote unquote you would<br>probably call it play<br>like play fighting let's start going<br>through our animals okay when you look<br>at the gorilla<br>you will see immediately that almost<br>every experience a gorilla has of combat<br>is theatrical<br>yes they don't engage in killing things<br>they scare rival males away in order to<br>gain ownership of females but there is<br>almost no<br>uh intra species death and those<br>conflicts they're almost entirely<br>theatrical they have for example<br>enormous<br>canine teeth but there is no record of<br>them ever being used in combat<br>um<br>they appear to be used purely for<br>intimidation purposes<br>there's a sense in which they have this<br>tremendous appearance and they have<br>tremendous potential they they really do<br>have freakish levels of strength<br>in in many different ways<br>and yet the actual track record of using<br>it is negligible it's so strange that<br>Evolution will develop such as a sewing<br>machine like they're bite force just<br>makes no sense with regard to what they<br>actually eat I think well no I I think<br>that even the presence of canines<br>doesn't make a lot of sense they're not<br>going to use them what are they it comes<br>down to this idea their big thing is<br>intimidation so as a show you wanna<br>uh fake it and don't care if you ever<br>make it because fake is good enough<br>given that particular Dynamic now let's<br>contrast that with<br>a male lion<br>'s<br>take on the biggest meanest<br>toughest animals in the most competitive<br>killing War<br>on planet Earth which is Continental<br>Africa<br>um and they<br>literally just take I mean occasionally<br>they lose but<br>it's rare and they take out everything<br>just in order to eat they have to take<br>down wildebeest cape buffalo they they<br>keep Buffalo are incredibly dangerous<br>beasts just by themselves and yet Lions<br>regularly take them down<br>um occasionally large numbers of lions<br>will even swarm elephant and over 12<br>hour periods take down elephant on some<br>occasions this is all on videos it's not<br>just speculation so they just have a<br>level of combat experience which no<br>other animal<br>if I were to also project so the the<br>Eastern European style of wrestling<br>where they spend so many hours on the<br>map they really value the number of<br>hours on the mat at play from childhood<br>the Lions probably for my extensive<br>watching videos on YouTube they seem to<br>play with each other yeah for fun a lot<br>and I guess even really helps you see it<br>you don't interact you don't play with<br>other gorillas you have<br>like you're more spending a lot more<br>time around<br>uh the opposite sex yeah so yeah I mean<br>even Lions uh when they they fight each<br>other the mortality rate when lions<br>fight each other male lions for<br>ownership of a pride<br>is very very high much much higher than<br>I believe any other species on Earth<br>um they're almost always fights to the<br>depth for the simple reason that when a<br>male lion loses control of a pride the<br>First Act the new lion does is to kill<br>the genetic offspring of the previous<br>male lion so when a lion fights another<br>male lion when one male lion fights<br>another it's not just a fight for his<br>own life it's a fight for his genetic<br>offspring and failure means not only<br>does he die<br>all his offspring dies and so when they<br>fight the implications are so deep it's<br>it's like a fight for your not just you<br>but your your DNA<br>um<br>most male lions have very short runs at<br>the top to get<br>killed or run off by by other Lions<br>um<br>now<br>this kind of harsh combat experience no<br>other animal can claim to have this<br>between what they kill to eat and what<br>they have to do to defend their their<br>stake and a pride<br>no other animal fights like that<br>um<br>they just bring a level of depth to<br>combat which is unmatched in the animal<br>kingdom they also have some other<br>elements too that they get to they get<br>the luxury because of their social<br>nature of taking more risks than other<br>animals like a tiger hunts alone so if<br>it gets injured it's a big problem it<br>can die if it's injured a lion can fight<br>uh cape buffalo get injured and be<br>covered by the other lions for food<br>until it recovers so it learns to take<br>risks and it's not afraid to go out and<br>fight very very hard whereas other<br>animals tend to shy away from risk<br>because they're solitary bears are<br>solitary that tigers are solitary so<br>they learned from an early age not to<br>take the big risks to go to a certain<br>level and stop if I could push back so<br>that's that's aggression and risk-taking<br>that's a plus for the lion but to defend<br>the gorilla because he says skill set<br>they are of all of those the only ones<br>that use tools I've shown to use tools<br>we didn't say anything about weapons a<br>gorilla could in theory pick up a rock<br>and it does have the like the force the<br>power and the capabilities to do a lot<br>of damage so it doesn't have the<br>practice it doesn't have the experience<br>but don't you think<br>if if a gorilla's back is to the wall so<br>you put them in a situation of it is<br>life and death<br>for both The Lion and the gorilla don't<br>you don't you value intelligence at<br>least a little bit here<br>um there's a reason why humans this is<br>like evidence that you know humans have<br>spread all across the world while being<br>kind of weak<br>why okay intelligence is a huge huge<br>asset humanity is positive proof that it<br>is the most important asset but it takes<br>time in order to<br>work is Magic it took humans<br>200 000 years to go from the bottom of<br>the food chain to the top of the food<br>chain<br>um and gorillas have a lot of work to do<br>before they get to that level uh you<br>said you said in theory gorillas could<br>do this but let's talk about practice<br>now first off there are many documented<br>incidents of leopards killing gorillas<br>that's that's anecdotal evidence no it's<br>not there's a bunch of bitch-ass<br>gorillas walking around we know this<br>we're asking not anecdotal it was<br>observed by a group of people who<br>specialized in in observing gorillas<br>over a 12-year period a regularly found<br>gorilla toes in lipidification<br>um they also saw that over a certain<br>period some 36 gorillas have been killed<br>and evidence strongly suggested leopard<br>predation was the reason apparently the<br>leopards had figured out that there is a<br>femoral artery<br>and gorilla's legs and we're doing a<br>move which from the sounds of it sounds<br>a lot like a baron bolo where they were<br>spinning underneath gorillas and biting<br>the femoral artery and then disengaging<br>and watching them bleed out and die and<br>then eating them now a leopard<br>is no match for a lion it the only<br>defense it has to align is to run up a<br>tree it cannot engage with a lion on<br>anything close to equal terms it may<br>seem like we're going out of tangents<br>but we're not just because of the foot<br>the attack of the artery and the foot<br>is there weaknesses that the lion might<br>have of that what I'm saying is I I know<br>it's not equivalent but the the fact<br>that a leopard does so well against even<br>fully grown male gorillas<br>makes you should make you rather<br>suspicious of a gorilla's ability to<br>fight a lion<br>fair enough let's also go further into<br>let's talk about concentration of force<br>the lion has the quintessential<br>concentration of force which is fangs<br>and claws<br>the gorilla is the exact opposite it<br>can't even make a fist<br>and so it can only throw open-handed<br>slaps and grab things so it it has no<br>ability with its with its arms to<br>concentrate force in any kind of<br>efficient way when a lion or a tiger<br>story or a bear for that matter swings<br>at you it's got four Claws from four to<br>six inches long it's like four blades<br>going into you they can retract their<br>claws so they're always sharp but the<br>reach is significantly longer for the<br>gorilla<br>the length of the the ability to engage<br>with speed on the part of the the cat is<br>is far far greater and also mobility and<br>to feed the bipedal nature of a gorilla<br>the the the temporary Barbados this is<br>the bear has the same no impact humans<br>are bipedal and lions kill 240 humans a<br>year on average<br>so okay okay okay what about bear now<br>beer is a difference for all the same<br>things that a lion has<br>the claws the teeth has more weight it<br>has more strength has more power<br>okay now this is an interesting question<br>okay you get a fully grown North<br>American Grizzly versus an African lion<br>this is an interesting fact I also have<br>questions about polar bears it's unclear<br>to me because they're big they're bigger<br>in every way than than a Grizzly yes but<br>they probably don't get the experience<br>in the practice yeah also they have a<br>much more limited set of uh animals that<br>they they Prey Upon so pretty sure<br>Grizzly is going to be tough to beat as<br>far as Top beer goes<br>um<br>um a grizzly bear<br>I believe would be a formidable<br>adversary even for a for a male lion<br>um that literally twice their size<br>they have an ability to get away from<br>strangleholds by standing up on two legs<br>so the Lion's primary method of killing<br>which is this strangle would be very<br>difficult for them to employ upon a bear<br>um<br>interestingly the Bear's primary method<br>of killing is to pin it pins animals and<br>then just slowly eats them while they're<br>still alive they have a rather barbaric<br>means of killing lions are much more<br>Humane in the way they kill<br>um<br>I what I see is the primary problem is<br>that neither one would ever be able to<br>kill the other uh that finishing thing<br>yeah they both fail on the finishing<br>criteria<br>the lion would not be able to strangle a<br>bear even in the best case scenario<br>where he got his teeth into the neck the<br>bear can stand up and and presumably<br>Shake him off<br>um uh the uh the the the the bear would<br>never be able to pin a lion for long<br>enough to better hold it down and and<br>slowly Maul it over time the way it can<br>with an elk or a caribou so I don't<br>believe either would be able to finish<br>the other it would just become exhausted<br>it would be it would come down to<br>endurance now that's where things get<br>interesting because the bear is much<br>more of an endurance Hunter and the line<br>is much more of an ambush Hunter lines<br>quick explosive much higher top speed<br>they've got a top speed of 45 to 50<br>miles an hour a beer can do up to 35 but<br>it can run for long periods at up to 25<br>miles an hour very long periods they're<br>mostly a uh an endurance Hunter they<br>just run<br>uh elk and moose down until they're<br>exhausted and then pin them and kill<br>them<br>so if it came down to endurance<br>might go the way of the beer if there<br>were if they were caged up together<br>however there is very strong evidence<br>from both hunters and video<br>which shows on many occasions beer is<br>being chased off by<br>cougar<br>and Wolverines<br>now what's that that's fear what is that<br>what do you mean chased off uh if they<br>fight over uh uh meat which uh and say<br>for example the cougar has killed<br>something and the bear wants to meet the<br>cougar will come there risk aversion<br>exactly exactly the Bears are<br>risk-averse what I would say is this the<br>beers are very very powerful in their<br>domain but they don't have the battle<br>experience of a lion they don't take on<br>animals as tough as a cape buffalo they<br>don't take on elephant what the toughest<br>thing it would probably take on probably<br>a a bull moose and uh a bull moose is a<br>formidable animal but it's nothing like<br>a cape buffalo it's nothing like an<br>elephant an elephant or a hippopotamus<br>so what I would suggest is this<br>in the wild I don't believe either one<br>is capable of killing the other but I do<br>believe based on video evidence of<br>cougars and Wolverines chasing off bears<br>that a lion would provide<br>enough threat<br>in a brief fight that a bear would back<br>away if you put them in a cage however<br>where neither one could back away I<br>would slightly favor the bear<br>based on the fact that it neither one<br>can kill each other would come down to<br>endurance you mean like an octagon yeah<br>that's got to be the next UFC by the way<br>beer versus<br>things change Joe Rogan's a big fan of<br>the idea of fighting in a stadium for<br>humans fighting in a stadium<br>um so in the stadium of bear I would I<br>would slightly favor a beer now I still<br>think that the lion would have a chance<br>but I would favor the Bear in a berry<br>match<br>um some of the best evidence we have for<br>animal versus animal fights come from<br>the ancient Romans who actually used to<br>put animals in gladiatorial combat and<br>um<br>they for example had several incidents<br>where they wrote about tiger vs lion<br>uh conflict and uh in one famous passage<br>they described a lion getting destroyed<br>by a a female tiger<br>um so there's there's some evidence to<br>suggest that they had more expertise of<br>this than we do because they they had a<br>big population of wild animals which<br>they just put to fight each other<br>um unfortunately there's nothing that<br>they wrote about beers versus lion they<br>did talk about uh bears versus bulls uh<br>they did talk about Lions versus Tigers<br>um but they never mentioned bear vs lion<br>so we don't have any evidence for that<br>so we have to be a little bit more<br>speculative now given that bears do get<br>chased off by cougar and cougar is weak<br>compared with a male lion they'll listen<br>to you draw from that by the way I would<br>suggest that is it about the Bears yeah<br>it's more about the bear like in theory<br>a beer should be able to crush a cougar<br>but it seems to be the beer is a scene<br>uh this thing could hurt me so I'm not<br>gonna risk injury and backs away I think<br>it would back away in the wild from a<br>lion but put him in a cage and I<br>slightly favor them the grizzly based on<br>endurance<br>so the final conclusion<br>if you had to just bet everything you<br>owned so you got uh let's say we got the<br>Octagon we bring in a bear<br>now this is like legendary bear okay<br>full grown Grizzly full grown Grizzly<br>but not only that that Grizzly is seeing<br>some [ __ ] what's the most it could have<br>seen a bull moose<br>a caribou that's the toughest opponent<br>has ever had it once no no no no no this<br>one once ran into a pack of other<br>Grizzlies and had to fend and he's got a<br>scarf Grizzlies there's no pack of<br>Grizzlies they're solitary wolves wolves<br>wolves what was a good practice for a<br>bear who attacks a bear that's that's my<br>point Bears don't really live in a<br>competitive environment lines but<br>sometimes it can get desperate as it was<br>a pack of wolves but that pack of wolves<br>is nothing that that's nothing all right<br>fine Lions deal with packs of hyenas<br>okay what was the just imagine over the<br>past hundred years what do you think is<br>the hardest fight<br>that a grizzly bear has been in like<br>somewhere in Alaska we never heard all<br>of a sudden in the middle of the night<br>all you hear is the bear just they<br>didn't really there's there's nothing<br>that does God have been something humans<br>have killed<br>cougars and Wolverines like no that's<br>anecdotal evidence there's got to be one<br>bear there's video footage of it you can<br>watch it yes it's called anecdotal<br>evidence there's got I guarantee you in<br>the dark of the night there was an epic<br>battle of which there's still Legend<br>amongst the Bears in that part of Canada<br>who did it battle in Canada moose are<br>the Bears you don't think they'd go at<br>it yeah bears fight each other but it's<br>largely theatrical they never kill each<br>other when lions fight each other they<br>kill each other all the time<br>like that someone would have seen it by<br>now interesting all right so so you're<br>seeing my point is it just they they<br>they they want to get their feet wet<br>they're giving no credit for gorillas so<br>you're saying lion wins your money's<br>online no I'm saying lion would win in<br>the wild because they they can't kill<br>each other they can't end the fight it's<br>one of our most important criteria<br>um but Lions can almost always initiate<br>the action because they have much better<br>uh uh ability to see at night for<br>example Bears have very average night<br>vision Lions have superb night vision so<br>at night time they can always initiate<br>the fight lions are natural Ambush<br>Predators so it's always going to be<br>able to have the advantage of Ambush<br>um the great advantage that bears have<br>is endurance uh but bears are very<br>risk-averse and they're not used to<br>fighting<br>like the toughest toughest animals the<br>toughest animal they fight is a moose or<br>a caribou these are not not even close<br>to the animals that Lions have to go up<br>against on a regular basis so if<br>somebody wins it's going to be the lion<br>for you I still think that the size and<br>endurance of the bear if they were<br>locked in a cage together I would still<br>favor the beer under those circumstances<br>but in the wild I believe the beer will<br>back away cut it in the cage no time<br>limit you favor the bear what if it's<br>five rounds or five minutes Championship<br>then I would go with a lion because the<br>lion has a huge speed Advantage so it's<br>gonna it's gonna injure it tear it up<br>and uh and do immediate damage like I<br>put it this way if lion and bear fight<br>first 15 minutes I favor the line 100<br>but then as time goes by that size and<br>weight is gonna and endurance is going<br>to have an effect I I'll bring up<br>shortly somebody that's going to<br>probably disagree with you about some<br>things hopefully it's a grizzly bear and<br>it comes in and just eats me<br>oh that would be so epic<br>um making a hell of a podcast I wonder<br>who you would eat first who would look<br>scarier more delicious I'm not sure the<br>black and white could either piss him<br>off he would think you were a penguin<br>is that a good thing or not no good if<br>it was a polar bear maybe it's different<br>um<br>deeply about your uh about athletes you<br>coached about people in your life<br>so I have to ask this question<br>if one of those athletes let's say<br>Gordon Ryan<br>now I was the dictator of the world and<br>this would entertain me so I force you<br>and Gordon to do this uh to fight uh a<br>bear or a lion Gordon has to uh how<br>would you coach him to do it<br>uh to have any chance of winning<br>he goes in empty hand empty-handed you<br>can choose Stadium or<br>um cage<br>Gordon Ryan empty-handed versus a lion<br>you get to choose lion versus bear it's<br>up to you okay my advice would be very<br>simple yeah I would say Gordon you're<br>[ __ ]<br>you're going to die badly<br>choose the lion because it will strangle<br>you to death rather than pin you down<br>and Maul you to death<br>didn't we just talk about audacious<br>goals<br>this is not a question of audacious gold<br>this is a question of minimizing pain so<br>you coach your athletes to quit before<br>the battle has been fought 100 yeah<br>what's he gonna do you don't think<br>there's a technic first of all<br>intelligence so technically what you<br>gotta do a heel hook no no well first of<br>all maybe you kind of do a Double A's or<br>four [ __ ] legs okay what if Gordon<br>gets any starting position he wants oh<br>yeah that's going to be really useful<br>on a thousand pound beer yeah<br>[Music]<br>shaken off he'll get torn off with what<br>like the reaches back he's got four or<br>six inches oh you can't get I wonder<br>what is the reach whatever he touches<br>he's got if it's not a flexible bear<br>so you think there's no control what<br>about like a low like a uh some kind of<br>controlling position from yeah like you<br>said purple like from underneath nothing<br>this discussion is so insane I didn't<br>even know where to begin criticism I<br>don't think you're open-minded we could<br>we could turn this down forget about<br>Gordon fighting a a lion or a bear<br>that's that's completely impossible an<br>adult male chimp will destroy Gordon<br>it's not even a gorilla<br>is more than enough to kill any human on<br>the planet including Gordon Ryan so<br>Gordon Ryan fighting a chimp a good size<br>dead no a thousand times how many times<br>does he win he loses a thousand times<br>it's not even competitive it's not even<br>remotely compared do you think he will<br>disagree<br>no<br>do you think anyone will disagree anyone<br>yeah [ __ ]